The tolerance itself is no problem with resistors, 1% or 10%, it wont make a big difference. Maybe one channel can be louder or something like that, but the sound itself is the same.
5% or 10% resistors consist of coal, the only disadvantage is some noise that can be heard at very high volumes.
But the main problem is: some of the resistors are magnetic... and this is what you can hear!
Some or most of the coal 5%/10% types have copper wires and connectors, they are non magnetic. Only some noise, but really good sound!
Metal film 1% types have (sometimes) a real metal wire inside, they are the worst what you can do for the sound, the sound is distorted because of inductions... it's like a coil. Very, very bad. And lots of Nickel inside, also magnetic
Metal oxide is better, just the caps can be Nickel, sometimes copper. If it is copper, ok, use it, they have low noise and no distortions.
The simple test is with a magnet: magnetic => dont use it !!!
Non magnetic :)
Quite the same is with capacitors: magnetic types have a worse sound...
Martin