I understand B&O independent franchise stores first get absorbed by B&O UK if they get into difficulties (i.e. don't meet targets), then presumably B&O UK decide on the closure (or not) which will inevitably be linked to numerous factors, including how long a building lease has to run etc.
As to the argument about whether stand alone stores are better than mixed, this will be the usual cyclical business decision that management drifts into. After having stand-alone store statistics for a period, someone will point out some disadvantages and someone will decide that mixed sales might be a better idea. Then in another 10 years, it will swing back again.
Look at Apple. In Liverpool you can buy at the Apple Store, PC World, John Lewis, and the latest is a large stand inside Costco for iPod products. Not to mention O2 phone shops who will presumably be dropping iPhones after the new Orange deal.
If you look at the range of products sold by the non exclusive Apple outlets, then you can imagine staffing costs as an overhead per product to be relatively low. The same for the Apple Store, always packed with customers. ( I don't know whether this Apple store is a franchise operation.) B&O is never going to turn-over low to mid priced products like Apple so presumably needs a different model (inc whole house installations.)
I can think of another exclusive high-end business (based on family in-studio photography)............ where franchises are reverting to HQ ownership and then closing all over the UK. Franchised high-end product stores may not be straightforward in a recession, even when you expect typical customers to be paying cash rather than buying on credit. For many people an iPhone/iPod/iMac remains a high priority (witness Apples share price). In a recession the same can't be said of studio photographs or, dare I say, the BV10 (Beoworld members excepted!))
Let's hope a recovering B&O can afford to take a longer-term view of franchise store support and survival!
Graham
I used to be indecisive, now I'm not so sure. [W C Fields]