Thanks Keith for your (yet another) comprehensive answer!
Situation 2 sounds similar to what's happening with my system - except I am using a Beocenter 9500.
It is interesting that PCB22 in the popping penta also has a fault which has caused the display to stop working.. I have swapped over that PCB between the 2 pentas and whichever it is installed in, the display does not work... I wonder whether there is more extensive damage on that board which is also causeing the pop? I guess I will find out when the new PCB22 arrives.
Unfortunately when I swapped the boards I was concentrating on the display problem, and can't recall whether the speaker was popping on the other penta.
I did notice that both input control boards have been 'modified (looks like it was at the factory) by isolating pin 1 of the powerlink sockets (tiny grind mark cutting the track, PCB21) and soldering 2 wires of the ribbon connector together (I have reassembled the units, so I can't say which two wires - the one which would have connected pin 1 powerlink to PCB22...?)
Pin1 is the 'power-up' signal so I suspect this was joined to pin4 the 'loudspeaker-on' signal...? I guess B&O must have had a reason for this...
Anyhow I think I'll wait and see whether the new PCB22 fixes the display issue and the popping issue before diving in with the soldering iron again!
Cheers, Steve