BeoGram

Re: Axel's re-tipping - MMC20EN or 20CL?

Cleviebaby — Tue, 24 Nov 2009 14:24:44 GMT

classic:

this high end solution:

Frede,

That sounds very interesting indeed. I'll contact Axel.

Cleve

Re: Axel's re-tipping - MMC20EN or 20CL?

classic — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 15:45:26 GMT

I would like to give you the latest news from Axel.

He can now deliver this high end solution:

Original Nude Shibata Diamant Nadel and CARBON Cantilever .

/Frede

Re: Axel's re-tipping - MMC20EN or 20CL?

Peter — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 14:42:30 GMT

It will not really be a CL - I think his ultimate re-tip is the Shibata tip that Soundproof reviewed. The innards of these cartridges are all the same - I don't know why the CL is so temperature sensitive compared to the EN as I don't believe the suspension material is any different.

Axel's re-tipping - MMC20EN or 20CL?

Cleviebaby — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 14:33:18 GMT

I know there are a couple of extensive posts on comparing Soundsmith cartridges with Axel's retipped ones, but my issue is slightly different.

I have a Beogram 4004 with an MMC 20EN that is starting to wear. The turntable feeds a Beomaster 4400 and at the moment I'm using S45.2s. Having been very impressed with a retipped MMC20S to 20E spec he did for me, I am tempted to get Axel to retip it to MMC20CL spec with a contact line stylus. However, I know that 20CLs are very temperature sensitive. Also, Axel's retipping uses an alluminium cantilever but the original 20CL had a saphire cantilever.

Has anyone noticed if Axel's retipped 20CLs are less temperature sensitive than the original or if there is any noticeable difference using an alluminium cantilever from the original saphire? Am I better getting it retipped as an EN to retain its original status? The cost differential is minimal, so that isn't an issue.

Cleve