I have a HDR1 and I am very happy with it. HDR2 is a bit better.
If you go for a non B&O device, I really suggest, like Peter that you go for an all-in-one Set top box + HD recorder.
A lot of them are supported by the STB-C or PUC of your TV.
The advantages are big over the direct control through Beo5.
- STB-C works with both Beo4 and Beo5.
- STB-C can control your box from a link room.
- You can use your TV timer.
What would help us helping you, would be to know how you get your TV? Terrestrial? SKY? Cable? Satellite? DVB-T?